south cambridgeshire (uk) based explorer - i post stuff i think is ok. sometimes i create summaries of others stuff. now & then I'll create content when inspired. it keeps me amused.
license
Where the stuff on this blog is something i created it is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License so there are no requirements to attribute - but if you want to mention me as the source that would be nice :¬)
Showing posts with label marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label marriage. Show all posts
Thursday, 17 February 2022
Sunday, 21 July 2013
Thursday, 4 October 2012
history of #christianity in 15 #objects - no. 3 #byzantine marriage crown
presented by the Rev'd Dr Simon Jones
in summary
- there are two crowns in a museum in athens, they are bronze and thought to be from the 10th century. they comprise of a narrow band raised at the front with a semi circular shape which would have covered the forehead

- hebrew scriptures have little about marriage and around 10th century bc its probably true to say that couples entered into a civil contract rather than a public commitment within a religious setting
- in the times nearer to christ forms of blessing prayer develop - possibly jewish couples were crowned in some way
- similarly the new testament has little on how early christians married so its reasonable to assume they followed the jewish practise which consisted of 1) a betrothal and then 2) the marriage itself (probably centred around a feast to which the bride and her attendants processed - possibly wearing a special gown and or a crown)
- moving to the 1st three centuries of christianity we still don't have that much to go on as far as liturgical details are concerned. generally there seems to have been a shift from a domestic rite (possibly lead by a family member or a cleric) to a church wedding presided over by a bishop or presbytery
- whenever such an approach was 1st used, by the 4th century crowns would have been part of many marriage ceremonies. they are thought to signify the spiritual triumph (over sensual passions?) of a couple who are united in christ
- unlike in the western church (an exchange or rings and of consent) the crowns were given to the couple by the church and this highlights a theological difference between the eastern and western churches on marriage. the east says church marries, the west says couple are ministers of a sacrament
- evidence from the 8th century for the byzantine rite suggests a ceremony consisting of betrothal and marriage (and the form of the rite is similar to what happens today in byzantine churches except betrothal and marriage rites are telescoped into one)
- whereas in the western tradition marriage is associated with eucharist and the highlight is the blessing of the wife, in the east the highlight is the crowning before the liturgy or the word
- in the east the giving of the rings is associated with betrothal not marriage, and the rite is betrothal of the couple to each other by the church. also in the eastern rite it is clear that those called to marriage are participating in the mystery of salvation and the life of the trinity in a particular way
- theologically marriage is not a sacrament christ initiated and its helpful to talk of the marriage of christians rather than of christian marriage
- the crowns help us to see that marriage is not only a gift of god to couples but also to the church and its mission
- and they challenge us to celebrate marriage as the generous hospitality of the trinitarian god, the source of all life and in whose gift it is to crown all things in love
Tuesday, 12 June 2012
summary of C of E response to gay marriage consultation
The Church of England's response to the consultation on equal civil marriage is in a press release and in a fuller submission here. The headline from these documents is that the CofE can't support the proposal to enable "all couples, regardless of their gender, to have a civil marriage ceremony".
I have summarised below the arguments put forward in these documents to support such a position.
Headline 1) - The proposed changes will change marriage for all - The proposals distinction between civil and religious marriage is an error - and the proposed change will change the way marriage is defined for everybody. Changing the State's understanding of marriage will change the way marriage (note - not the CofE wedding ceremony) is defined for everybody and so will change the nature of marriages solemnized in churches and other places of worship. (Note Anyone who is resident in England has a legal right to marry in his or her parish church irrespective of his or her religious affiliation and the minister of the parish is under a legal duty to conduct the marriage.)
Headline 2) - Safeguarding assurances for religions have little force - once this change is made assurances from Government of safeguarding of religious organisations position on marriage would be of limited value. Once the law was changed that safeguarding would be challenged with discrimination claims in European courts. (the arguments would likely be that to remove the concept of gender from marriage while leaving it in place for civil partnerships is unlikely to prove legally sustainable and that it seems extremely doubtful that the European court would uphold the right of a state to retain gender inequality in civil partnerships once the state had legislated for "equal marriage"). In addition it is unlikely to prove politically sustainable to prevent same sex weddings in places of worship given that civil partnerships can already be registered there where the relevant religious authority consents.
I have summarised below the arguments put forward in these documents to support such a position.
Headline 1) - The proposed changes will change marriage for all - The proposals distinction between civil and religious marriage is an error - and the proposed change will change the way marriage is defined for everybody. Changing the State's understanding of marriage will change the way marriage (note - not the CofE wedding ceremony) is defined for everybody and so will change the nature of marriages solemnized in churches and other places of worship. (Note Anyone who is resident in England has a legal right to marry in his or her parish church irrespective of his or her religious affiliation and the minister of the parish is under a legal duty to conduct the marriage.)
Headline 2) - Safeguarding assurances for religions have little force - once this change is made assurances from Government of safeguarding of religious organisations position on marriage would be of limited value. Once the law was changed that safeguarding would be challenged with discrimination claims in European courts. (the arguments would likely be that to remove the concept of gender from marriage while leaving it in place for civil partnerships is unlikely to prove legally sustainable and that it seems extremely doubtful that the European court would uphold the right of a state to retain gender inequality in civil partnerships once the state had legislated for "equal marriage"). In addition it is unlikely to prove politically sustainable to prevent same sex weddings in places of worship given that civil partnerships can already be registered there where the relevant religious authority consents.
Headline 3) - Civil partnership couldn't be limited to just same-sex couples - if the law were changed so that same-sex couples were able to marry, the legitimate aim of providing civil partnerships for same-sex couples only would cease to exist and there is therefore a real question as to whether the line taken in the consultation paper that civil partnerships would remain limited to same-sex couples would withstand legal challenge.
Headline 4) - Marriage would change to voluntary union between 2 people - so a man and a woman who wished to enter into the traditional institution of marriage would no longer have the opportunity to do so. Only the new, statutory institution, which defined a "marriage" as the voluntary union of any two persons, would be available.
Headline 4) - Marriage would change to voluntary union between 2 people - so a man and a woman who wished to enter into the traditional institution of marriage would no longer have the opportunity to do so. Only the new, statutory institution, which defined a "marriage" as the voluntary union of any two persons, would be available.
Headline 5) - Governments don't have the right to change ages old social institutions - as enshrined in human institutions throughout history (from before the advent of church or state). Many, within the churches and beyond, dispute the right of any government to redefine an ages-old social institution in the way proposed.
Headline 6) - This change alters the intrinsic nature of marriage as the union of a man and a woman - which embodies the underlying, objective distinctiveness of men and women. Such marriage affords many benefits to society, which include mutuality, fidelity and the possibility of procreation.
Headline 6) - This change alters the intrinsic nature of marriage as the union of a man and a woman - which embodies the underlying, objective distinctiveness of men and women. Such marriage affords many benefits to society, which include mutuality, fidelity and the possibility of procreation.
Headline 7) - Civil partnerships already provide for same sex couples - by providing a framework within which same sex couples can exhibit the social virtues of fidelity and mutuality. Legislating to change the definition of a fundamental and historic social institution for everybody in order to meet the emotional need of some members of one part of the community, where no substantive inequality of rights will be rectified, seems a doubtful use of the law.
Headline 8) - There are no obvious legal gains to such a change - to change the nature of marriage for everyone will deliver no obvious additional legal gains to those already now conferred by civil partnerships. Imposing, for essentially ideological reasons, a new meaning on a term as familiar and fundamental as marriage would be deeply unwise.
Headline 8) - There are no obvious legal gains to such a change - to change the nature of marriage for everyone will deliver no obvious additional legal gains to those already now conferred by civil partnerships. Imposing, for essentially ideological reasons, a new meaning on a term as familiar and fundamental as marriage would be deeply unwise.
Headline 9) - The consultation overlooks the impact on the position of the established Church. In common with almost all other Churches, the Church of England holds, as a matter of doctrine and derived from the teaching of Christ himself, that marriage in general – and not just the marriage of Christians – is, in its nature, a lifelong union of one man with one woman. The Church or England‘s teaching on marriage is embodied in Canon law which is part of the law of England. Were legislation to be enacted by Parliament that changed the definition of marriage for the purposes of the law of England, the status and effect of the canonical provisions (that set out the Church‘s doctrine of marriage as being between one man and one woman) would be called into question. In this way the consultation overlooks the implications of what is proposed for the position of the established Church and so the CofE's ability to serve the people of the nation as they have always done.
Headline 10) - Leaving it to the courts to establish a new definition for adultery is unsatisfactory - the consultation document leaves the question of defining adultery, non-consummation etc. to be determined by case law which the CofE thinks is unsatisfactory. Having identical reasons for ending both a same-sex and a heterosexual marriage is problematic and does not seem to be achievable given that the existing definitions of adultery and non-consummation cannot be applied to the case of a same-sex marriage.
Headline 11) - The consultation prejudges the outcome - as the exercise has been unsatisfactory because the consultation document prejudges the outcome in 3 ways:
a) by expressing the issues in prejudicial terms which pre-empt the principles on which it purports to consult (e.g. using language like - how the ban can be lifted on same sex couples having a marriage);
a) by expressing the issues in prejudicial terms which pre-empt the principles on which it purports to consult (e.g. using language like - how the ban can be lifted on same sex couples having a marriage);
b) by asserting the existence of a non-existent concept - religious marriage - (there is no distinction in law between religious and civil marriage);
c) by asserting opinions as undisputed facts - e.g. that the commitment made between a man and a man, or a woman and a woman in a civil partnership is as significant as the commitment between a man and a woman in a civil marriage (If one of the significant elements of the commitment that a man and a woman generally make to each other in marriage is to be open to bringing children into the world as a fruit of their loving commitment, then the commitment of same-sex couples - whatever its virtues - cannot be acknowledged as identical).
c) by asserting opinions as undisputed facts - e.g. that the commitment made between a man and a man, or a woman and a woman in a civil partnership is as significant as the commitment between a man and a woman in a civil marriage (If one of the significant elements of the commitment that a man and a woman generally make to each other in marriage is to be open to bringing children into the world as a fruit of their loving commitment, then the commitment of same-sex couples - whatever its virtues - cannot be acknowledged as identical).
Sunday, 29 January 2012
sex, marriage & fairytales
i realized disney movies and chick flicks, they’ve put us in a weird position,
they’ve distorted our reality, we forget they are fiction,
because in marriage we either get better or bitter, either joy or remorses,
whatever were doing ain’t working, just look at the rate of divorces
so, how’s your marriage? i mean c’mon let’s just be honest,
marriage seems to some more like a prison, than the paradise they were promised
we thought marriage was supposed to fulfill us and make us happy, not lonely
but the truth is his first priority is making you holy.
you say “no one told me,” and it feels so odd
that dating felt like a vacation, while marriage feels like a job,
yet the secret of joy, if we just pull back our facade,
Is realizing most problems arise when we elevate our spouse to God
Without knowing it we’ve fulfilled romans 1:25
by our actions exchanged the truth about god for a lie,
we’ve exchanged god for lesser, created things,
it’s like a husband trading his wife for a 2d image on a screen,
hoping it’ll set us free, just to find on the fumes were choking,
cuz if your marriage rests on anything but jesus, it’s resting on something broken.
yet guys continually sacrifice their marriage on the altar of sex and lust,
i mean if our dollars were honest they’d say in “pleasure we trust”
so men grow up, put down the controller,
how about you lead her with grace, instead of trying to control her
now I’ve never been married but I’m a product of one that was non-existent,
so don’t tell me I don’t understand, don’t tell me I just don’t get it
so for the singles, become friends first, before you become lovers,
pursue christ as your foundation, before you get under the covers,
because believe me a strong friendship before marriage, will make a good marriage after,
friendship isn’t just sex, its deep conversation and laughter.
i mean some spouses barely even like each other, and the marriage seems like a dead end.
you might share a checkbook and a bed, but are you actually friends?
i mean if marriage isn’t a commitment, then what’s the point of the vows we say?
til death do us apart, really means until the feelings goes away.
like, “ill stay with him but only until it gets tough and my love shifts”,
but I say imagine if a parent took that perspective with her kids,
Like can’t you see it, the minute the kid spills food on the floor,
the mom saying “son I’m leaving, i’m just not in love with you anymore.”
no its just like marriage, to last you need the strength from above,
because it’s not the love that sustains the promise, it’s the promise that sustains the
love.
i mean think about it, out of anyone who has had the right to leave?
god had every reason in the world, yet he still came for you and me,
and on the cross he paid it all he took our shame and set us free,
when he could’ve called down legions of angels, he chose to stay on that tree.
from the cross he looks you in the eye, and says I’m taking this for my bride,
when you trust in me, you no longer have to hide!
because of me it is finished, you have been made new!
spotless, blameless there’s no sin in you!
his death was a proposal, he wanted you no matter the cost,
where some guys propose on a knee, jesus proposed on a cross.
so whether husband or wife, read ephesians 5,
wife honor your husband, husbands give up your life,
just like jesus gave himself, for his bride the church,
so men lead by serving, by putting her first
lastly both spouses die to self, put your flesh on a life sentence,
because you don’t fall out of love as much as you fall out of repentance.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)