license

Creative Commons License
Where the stuff on this blog is something i created it is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License so there are no requirements to attribute - but if you want to mention me as the source that would be nice :¬)
Showing posts with label best practice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label best practice. Show all posts

Friday, 28 July 2017

4min 49sec #TEDEd clip - How to #practice #effectively...for just about anything - Annie Bosler and Don Greene


From their YouTube commentary

View full lesson: http://ed.ted.com/lessons/how-to-prac...

Mastering any physical skill takes practice. Practice is the repetition of an action with the goal of improvement, and it helps us perform with more ease, speed, and confidence. But what does practice actually do to make us better at things? Annie Bosler and Don Greene explain how practice affects the inner workings of our brains.

Lesson by Annie Bosler and Don Greene, animation by Martina Meštrović.

Thursday, 14 May 2015

18 #management practices to measure good management & 10 conclusions on the #data gathered on such across firms and countries


The points I make below are summarised out of this paper - Why Do Management Practices Differ across Firms and Countries? - by Nicholas Bloom and John Van Reenen (there is more detail on the authors towards the end of this post) 

The paper was published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 24, Number 1—Winter 2010—Pages 203–224


At the foot of this page are links to other posts you maybe interested in


The methodology they used to measure management was to use an interview-based evaluation tool to score firms (1 = worst practice to 5 = best practice) against 18 basic management practices (listed below).  The main measure of management practices was taken as simply the average of the 18 scores against these practices.  The 18 practices cover 3 broad areas:


1) monitoring- what goes on inside a firm and how this is used for continuous improvement; 

2) targets- right targets set? right outcomes tracked? & action taken if the 2 are inconsistent;

3) incentives - promotion/reward based on performance plus firms hire and keep best staff





The 18 management practices


1) Introduction of modern manufacturing techniques - e.g. just-in-time delivery,  from suppliers, intelligent automation, flexible manpower, support systems, attitudes & behaviour


2) Rationale for introduction of modern manufacturing techniques - e.g. adopted just because others have or because linked to meeting business objectives?


3) Process problem documentation - e.g improvements only made when problems arise or actively and continuously sought as a normal part of business?


4) Performance tracking  - e.g. ad hoc/incomplete or continually tracked and communicated to staff?


5) Performance review  - e.g. infrequent & on a success/failure scale or continual with an expectation of continuous improvement?


6) Performance dialogue - e.g. is the purpose, data, agenda, and follow-up steps clear to all parties?


7) Consequence management - does failure to achieve agreed objectives carry consequences? 


8) Target balance - e.g. are goals exclusively financial or is there a balance with non-financial targets?


9) Target interconnection - e.g are goals based on accounting value or on shareholder value in a way that works through business units and connects to individual performance expectations?


10) Target time horizon - e.g. does top management focus mainly on the short term or see short term targets as a “staircase” toward long-term goals?


11) Targets are stretching  - e.g. are goals too easy/demanding and are they attainable for all parts of the firm?


12) Performance clarity  - e.g. are measures ill-defined, poorly understood and private or are they well-defined, clearly communicated, and made public?


13) Managing human capital - e.g. to what extent are senior managers evaluated and held
accountable for attracting, retaining, and developing talent throughout the organization?


14) Rewarding high performance - e.g. to what extent are people rewarded equally irrespective of performance level, or are rewards related to performance and effort?


15) Removing poor performers  - e.g. are poor performers rarely removed, or are they retrained and/or moved into different roles or out as soon as the weakness is identified?


16) Promoting high performers - e.g. are people promoted mainly on the basis of tenure or does the firm actively identify, develop, and promote its top performers?


17) Attracting human capital  - e.g. do competitors offer stronger reasons for talented people to join them or does the firm provide a wide range of reasons to encourage talented people to join?


18) Retaining human capital  - e.g. Does the firm do little to retain top talent or do whatever it takes to retain top talent when they look likely to leave?



and the 10 conclusions reached on management practices based on the data they gathered against the 18 management practices are:


1) firms with better practices tend to have better performance on a wide range of dimensions


2) practices vary tremendously across firms and countries with much of the difference between countries due to the size of the “long tail” of very badly managed firms. 


3) countries and firms specialize in different styles of management (e.g. USA firms score much higher than Swedish firms in incentives but are worse than Swedish firms in monitoring)


4) strong product market competition appears to boost average practices (through a combination of eliminating the tail of badly managed firms and pushing incumbents to improve their practices)


5) multinationals are generally well managed in every country (they also transplant their management styles abroad)


6) firms that export (but do not produce) overseas are better-managed than domestic non-exporters, but are worse-managed than multinationals. 


7) inherited family-owned firms who appoint a family member (especially the eldest son) as chief executive officer are very badly managed on average. 


8) government-owned firms are typically managed extremely badly. Firms with publicly quoted share prices or owned by private-equity firms are typically well managed. 


9) firms that more intensively use human capital (as measured by more educated workers) tend to have much better practices


10) at a country level, a relatively light touch in labour market regulation is associated with better use of incentives by management.



More detail on the authors

Nicholas Bloom ( email nbloom@stanford.edu ) is an Associate Professor of Economics, Stanford University, Stanford, California, an International Research Fellow

John Van Reenen (email j.vanreenen@lse.ac.uk )is a Professor of Economics, London School of Economics, London, United Kingdom, Director of the Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics, London, United Kingdom and Research Fellow in the Centre for Economic Policy, London, United Kingdom. 

Both authors are also Faculty Research Fellows, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Massachusetts. 


other posts on RSA, TED, other lectures, conferences, others blog posts

2015

algorithmically enhanced confirmation bias - 6 uncomfortable facts about how facebook affects what we see - from a post by @nathanjurgenson

10 thoughts on some possible insights (& questions) from the UK Election results
11 headlines on why we use facebook & social media - summarised out of a very rich buffer post by Courtney Seiteron  
18 top tips and thoughts about using #social media to enable #community source = an article by  Anatoliy Gruzd PhD & Caroline Haythornthwaite PhD 

2014
Data Protection & Privacy - 8 issues from an International Conference
escape your social horizon limit & understand more - source = a blog post summarising the work of  Jeffrey A. Smith, Miller McPherson & Lynn Smith-Lovin
social media & death - 10 things you may not have thought about - #DORS conference

2013
the development of the U2 spyplane - source = CIA historians Gregory Pedlow & Donald Welzenbach
considering culture and business process improvement  - source = an article by Schmiedel, Theresa, vom Brocke, Jan, & Recker 
ideas that may help you attract older volunteers - source = a paper by Brayley, Nadine, Obst, Patricia L., White, Katherine M., Lewis, Ioni M.,Warburton, Jeni, & Spencer, Nancy
physical factors which help people get better quicker - source = a paper by Salonen, Heidi & Morawska, Lidia 
a new approach to school and education - by Geetha Narayanan 
guiding principles on designing construction kits - by Mitchel Resnick & Brian Silverman
signs of overparenting - source = an article by Locke, Judith, Campbell, Marilyn A., & Kavanagh, David J
making ideas happen - source = a 99U conference

2012
how to spot a liar - by pamela myer 
measuring happiness - source = talk by jim clifton, jim harter, ben leedle


Wednesday, 25 June 2014

Strategy Best Practice - 10 thoughts to ponder

(ht microsoft clip art for the pic)
This is the 4th weekly Wednesday post on #cofestrategy.  

It is based on my review of the strategy documents on the CofE Diocese and  HQ websites as at May/June 2014.

The 1st post in this series was Strategy Headline Statements – a summary of key words each diocese uses.

The 2nd post was Strategy Subject Checklist - a summary of key subjects covered by diocese strategy.


The 3rd post was on Strategy Measures -  a summary of those used by the various diocese strategy.


The 4th post (this) was on Strategy Best Practice - 10 thoughts to ponder.


The 5th post was a Summary of each diocese strategy with links to key documents and websites


The 6th post was a Selection of the graphics & analogies used in some of the diocese strategy

The 7th post was Theology/thinking behind some of the various cofe strategy - with links to documents




What led to this post was that - in reading through the strategy documents and website pages - various thoughts crossed my mind on what seemed to be Best Practice.  

I hope these thoughts are useful prompts if you are working on a strategy.  If you want to offer alternative views via comments to enrich this post's usefulness please do so.



1) Theology behind the Strategy

Best Practice was when there was a specific document or presentation on the theological basis for the strategy. 

Some diocese wove such explanations into the materials presenting the strategy.  

Though explicit this does require the reader to do far more work to unearth the theology.


2) Top Down or?

Best Practice was when there was an explicit explanation of whether the strategy was top down guidance (or more strongly direction/expectation) from the bishops.  In such cases it helped if there was an explanation of the reasoning behind such direction  Similarly where the approach was bottom up it was useful when the basis for this was explained.  

So in one example of bottom up  - the explanation was that the Mission Action Plans of each church - as reviewed by the bishops - had formed the basis for the common themes they had identified.

It felt more awkward when the strategy adopted an approach popular in some businesses of presenting the strategy as the result of consultation.  Experiences from the business world would often lead people to view such consultations as lip service.

Some Strategy also dealt with the often uncommented upon tension between a Diocese centre consuming resources and parishes largely paying for such.  In one case there was an explicit target to reduce how much of the parish share went to financing the centre.

I didn't find much evidence of clear statements about what issues should rightly be led by the Diocese (e.g. resourcing, facilitating sharing) and which should be led by the parishes/deanery (e.g. planting new churches, work with local schools).



3) Timescales

Best Practice was when the timescale for the strategy was stated (eg. 2016 or 2020).  This was enhanced when the reasoning behind the timescale was explained.  

So in one example the  explanation for the timescale was that it would cover the period most affected by the significant changes arising from the retirement of baby boomer clergy.

In another case the timescale of 3 years was explained in terms of how each year different aspects of  the strategy will be focused on,



4) Review

Best Practice was when the strategy explained the mechanism/structure/timescale for how the strategy itself would be reviewed.  

This was made better when specific measures were mentioned or it was explained how the strategy itself would be reviewed and measured in light of its progress and changes to its key drivers.

What wasn't dealt with often was how the reviews would also deal with the emotional aspects of change OR how they would deal with significant changes to key assumptions OR new insight from statistical research on church growth.

So by way of example  - a key theme many strategy had was of more lay involvement. Therefore a key assumption for many strategy is around how available lay people are whilst working or after retirement. 

With difficult employment conditions, fewer people with adequate pensions, and more grandparents providing childcare for grandchildren  - some would argue lay people's availability is going to decrease not increase.



5) Achievements

Best Practice was when there was a clear articulation - and celebration - of what had already been achieved.

I also found it more helpful when the strategy was clear about what church members ought to aim for in terms of change or achievements,


6) Documents available on-line

Best Practice was when the various documents supporting the strategy were gathered together on a resources page on the website.  Where this was the case, and key Diocesan Synod papers were also available on-line I thought this helped create trust.  

However when Synod papers were not available - or previous versions of papers appear to have disappeared - I found it hard not to start to become suspicious (as in what are they hiding and why?).



7) Telling the story of the development of the strategy

Where this was done it was a lot easier to understand how the structure and language of the strategy had developed over time and to see the refinements made to it.

It also helped set down some of the experiences in how thinking developed which - I imagine - may help future strategy learn better from the past.



8) Graphics,logos and analogies

Best Practice was when the explanation of the structure and elements of the strategy was supported by the use of diagrams and graphics or logos for each major area.  

Some Diocese also used analogies (e.g. its like a cheesecake) to explain the strategy structure.   I thought this would help communicate in a way more understandable to those who have not been exposed to business strategy terminology.



9) Hierarchy of Strategy Terminology.  

Best Practice was the Strategy explained explicitly the terminology it used  OR when the strategy authors specifically pointed out when  hierarchy did not apply.  Examples

- When there was a hierarchy  - the use of diagrams to visualise it. 

- When there wasn't a hierarchy - specific explanations of how the 1st priority wasn't the most important and that the priorities were co-equal.  In another case it was explicitly stated that the priorities did not mean resources would not be applied to other activities not covered by the priorities.



10) Consistency of terminology used

This seems obvious but in some cases the language used in a vision or mission statement was different across different documents or website pages. So for example what was called a theme in one place was called something different in another place.  

I suspect many of these differences were because the documents and website pages represented different versions of the strategy during its evolution.  Point 7 above helps deal with such differences.