license

Creative Commons License
Where the stuff on this blog is something i created it is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License so there are no requirements to attribute - but if you want to mention me as the source that would be nice :¬)
Showing posts with label brexit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label brexit. Show all posts

Tuesday, 11 June 2024

A brave civil servant telling it like it is - maybe something that more of our politicans could aspire to

 

Obviously the right will see the clip above as a woke anti brexit liberal elite blob attack on their tremendously successful delivery record since Brexit.

Whereas I see it as a remarkable brave civil servant telling it like it is. 

As a reminder to all politicians, that is what public service is about. Speaking truth to power.

Some of the politicians still seem to get that.  But some of them behave as though public service is pimarily a route to increasing their own wealth.

Speaking truth to power is what public service is about.  Even if it means you don't get that promotion, or that honour, or that seat in the Lords, or that Executive Director/Consultant post in the private sector. 

And the right and the left don't really want to talk about Brexit because - you know - its water under the bridge and so what. 

For the right - they don't want to admit their lack of delivering the "take back control" opportunities. 

For the left - they don't want to talk about Brexit because - with a 48% to 52% ish split on the Brexit vote, they can't get beyond their fear of the electoral maths to be able to say the whole Brexit thing was a con. 

And on immigration neither the left or the right seem able to engage in a sensible debate.
.  
Some politicians tell us to fear immigrants as the cause for most of our unhappiness.

Yet the stranger, the immigant, has always being part of what made our economy and democracy and country strong - for centuries and centuries. 

Given that we have an ageing population, the sensible debate on immigration is - given our care services and other resourcing needs -  how much immigration do we need to fill the gaps - and can our communities live with the consequencies of that level of immigration?

Neither do any of the parties want to talk about the reality that - if you choose to not believe in ridiculous UK economy growth forecasts, or the same moronic forecasts on how we'll get the tax dodgers - then the reality is we're all in for a for a bit of a financial shock when the election is over.

On the no more taxes front - to get you ready for the fiscal reality that will eventually play out after the election  ...

- either we can't afford to have everything we want - so according to our individual economic wealth we'll be able to ride that storm out (look at the increasingly no. of people who can afford it, having operations in the private health sector) OR for the 1 in 6 of us who have effectively no or little savings - we'll be stuffed ...

- and/or somebody will have to get taxed more (according to the right and the left thats not income tax, national insurance or pensioners paying tax) so that leaves only a few options (apart from not increasing tax thresholds so inflation moves more and more of us ionto higher tax brackets)

- I've concluded that the current 2024 election topics of debate between the parties appear to be pitched at such a basic pureile level that the only thing they indicate is how low the talent level in our politicians has sunk, or how low their ambition to have an honest and thoughtful public debate has fallen.


Friday, 1 January 2021

Fact Update - Under the xmas eve #Brexit Agreement its simply not true that the #UK is #unfettered in its control of its own regulations

When Boris Johnson, the UK Prime Minister, announced on xmas eve 2020 that the EU and UK were both signing up to a Brexit Agreement I couldn't quite believe it.  I thought hats off to the EU & UK for avoiding the economic disaster that would have flowed from no deal.

In his announcement Boris said the UK had taken back control of a number of things, for example, "We have taken back control of every jot and tittle of our regulation in a way that is complete and unfettered," (the full text from the British PM's xmas eve announcement is at the foot of this post).

Now just because a deal has been done doesn't mean that the 48.1% of those who voted against Brexit will be happy.  For many of them leaving the EU is still a bad idea.

But for the 51.9% who voted yes to Brexit I initially thought they could all have a bit of a xmas celebration.  After all, as Boris had set out on xmas eve, a no deal had been avoided and the UK had taken back control.

Given that our PM's previous announcements have previously been criticised as been bombastic, I thought I'd better actually check that what he said in his announcement was actually true.  To do this fact check comprehensively I'd have to read all 1246 pages of the agreement - and frankly I doin't have the time for that.  

So instead I read the UK Governments summary of the agreement, and the EU's summary materials also.

If you voted for leaving the EU and getting back control you're not going to like what I found.

The Agreement between the EU and the UK is basically a commitment to ensure a level playing field between the parties.

If one side thinks that commitment has been breached it can suspend its own obligations in a proportionate way.  Breaches are submitted to an independent arbitration panel.  If that panel find a breach has taken place then the offending party has to rectify the breach or provide compensation for its effects.  Either side needs to give 12 months notice to terminate the agreement.

As paragraph 81 on page 18 of the UK's "Summary Explainer" says  - my emphasis - "Both sides have the right to set their own laws, subject to the broad constraints of this Agreement in this area as in any other. And both sides have the right, in certain constrained ways, and subject to arbitration, to take countermeasures if they believe they are being damaged by measures taken by the other Party in subsidy policy, labour and social policy, or climate and environment policy. If such measures are used too frequently either side can trigger a review of these provisions and the trade aspects of the Treaty more broadly, aiming to end with a different balance of rights and obligations."

So what the PM said, that the UK is unfettered in its control of its own regulations, is factually incorrect.

Instead of having his cake and eating it Boris appears to have failed to get the cake into his mouth and has instead smeared it all over his face to demonstrate what a clown he is.



Text of British PMs Xmas Eve 2020 Brexit Deal Announcement

"It is four and a half years since the British people voted to take back control of their money, their borders, their laws, and their waters and to leave the European Union.  And earlier this year we fulfilled that promise and we left on January 31 with that oven-ready deal.  Since that time we have been getting on with our agenda, enacting the points-based immigration system that you voted for and that will come into force on January 1, and doing free trade deals with 58 countries around the world and preparing the new relationship with the EU.  And there have been plenty of people who have told us that the challenges of the Covid pandemic have made this work impossible, and that we should extend the transition period and incur yet more delay.  And I rejected that approach precisely because beating Covid is our number one national priority and I wanted to end any extra uncertainty and to give this country the best possible chance of bouncing back strongly next year.

And so I am very pleased that this afternoon that we have completed the biggest trade deal yet, worth £660 billion.  A comprehensive Canada style free trade deal between the UK and the EU, a deal that will protect jobs across this country.  A deal that will allow UK goods and components to be sold without tariffs and without quotas in the EU market.  A deal which will if anything should allow our companies and our exporters to do even more business with our European friends, and yet which achieves something that the people of this country instinctively knew was doable but which they were told was impossible.

We have taken back control of laws and our destiny.  We have taken back control of every jot and tittle of our regulation in a way that is complete and unfettered.  From January 1 we are outside the customs union, and outside the single market.  British laws will be made solely by the British Parliament, interpreted by UK judges sitting in UK courts.  And the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice will come to an end.  

We will be able to set our own standards, to innovate in the way that we want, to originate new frameworks for the sectors in which this country leads the world, from biosciences to financial services, artificial intelligence and beyond.  We will be able to decide how and where we are going to stimulate new jobs and new hope, with freeports and new green industrial zones.  We will be able to cherish our landscape and our environment in the way we choose, backing our farmers and backing British food and agricultural production.  

And for the first time since 1973 we will be an independent coastal state with full control of our waters with the UK’s share of fish in our waters rising substantially from roughly half today to closer to two thirds in five and a half years’ time after which there is no theoretical limit beyond those placed by science or conservation on the quantity of our own fish that we can fish in our waters.  And to get ready for that moment those fishing communities we will be helped with a big £100 million programme to modernise their fleets and the fish processing industry.

And I want to stress that although of course the arguments with our European friends and partners were sometimes fierce this is, I believe a good deal for the whole of Europe and for our friends and partners as well.  Because it will not be a bad thing for the EU to have a prosperous and dynamic and contented UK on your doorstep, it will be a good thing, it will drive jobs and prosperity across the whole continent.  And I don’t think it will be a bad thing if we in the UK do things differently, or a take a different approach to legislation, because in so many ways our basic goals are the same.  

And in the context of this giant free trade zone that we’re jointly creating the stimulus of regulatory competition will, I think, benefit us both.  And if one side believes it is somehow being unfairly undercut by the other, then, subject to independent third party arbitration and provided the measures are proportionate, we can either of us decide, as sovereign equals, to protect our consumers.

But this treaty explicitly envisages that such action should only happen infrequently and the concepts of uniformity and harmonisation are banished in favour of mutual respect and mutual recognition and free trade.

And for squaring that circle, for finding the philosopher’s stone that’s enabled us to do this I want to thank President von der Leyen of the European Commission and our brilliant negotiators led by Lord Frost and Michel Barnier, on the EU side Stephanie Rousseau as well as Oliver Lewis, Tim Barrow, Lindsay Appleby and many others. Their work will be available for scrutiny, followed by a parliamentary vote, I hope, on December 30.

This agreement, this deal above all means certainty.  It means certainty for the aviation industry and the hauliers who have suffered so much in the Covid pandemic.  It means certainty for the police and the border forces and the security services and all those that we rely on across Europe to keep us safe.  It means certainty for our scientists who will be able to continue to work together on great collective projects, because although we want the UK to be a science superpower, we also want to be a collaborative science superpower.  And above all it means certainty for business from financial services to our world-leading manufacturers, our car industry, certainty for those working in high skilled jobs in firms and factories across the whole country.

Because there will be no palisade of tariffs on January 1, and there will be no non-tariff barriers to trade.  And instead there will be a giant free trade zone of which we will at once be a member and at the same time be able to do our own free trade deals as one UK, whole and entire, England, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales together.

And I should stress this deal was done by a huge negotiating team from every part of the UK, and it will benefit every part of our United Kingdom, helping to unite and level up across the country.  And so I say again directly to our EU friends and partners, I think this deal means a new stability and a new certainty in what has sometimes been a fractious and difficult relationship. We will be your friend, your ally, your supporter and indeed, never let it be forgotten, your number one market.

Because although we have left the EU, this country will remain culturally, emotionally, historically, strategically and geologically attached to Europe, not least through the four million EU nationals who have requested to settle in the UK over the last four years and who make an enormous contribution to our country and to our lives.  

And I say to all of you at home, at the end of this toughest of years, that our focus in the weeks ahead is of course on defeating the pandemic.  And on beating coronavirus and rebuilding our economy and delivering jobs across the country and I am utterly confident that we can and will do it.  

By today we have vaccinated almost 800,000 people and we have also today resolved a question that has bedevilled our politics for decades, and it is up to us all together, as a newly and truly independent nation, to realise the immensity of this moment and to make the most of it.

Happy Christmas to you all.   That’s the good news from Brussels – now for the sprouts.

Sunday, 30 December 2018

59min @RSAEvents clip - 2018: The Year in Review | Catherine Mayer | RSA Replay



Text from youtube "Who are we as a nation as the year draws to a close?

From the Cambridge Analytica revelations to the Trump baby balloon to the Windrush scandal, it’s been another year of tumultuous news and turbulent politics.

Alongside a Brexit process plagued by deadlocks, defeats, and resignations, the big moments of the year – from the Irish abortion referendum to Labour’s antisemitism row – have revealed deep divisions in our society and our politics. How can we understand the stories that have dominated this year’s headlines in the context of such polarisation? What do identity politics have to do with it? And are we really descending into ‘culture wars’?

As 2018 comes to an end, we gather a panel of expert commentators to reflect on the world-shaping headlines that have defined this extraordinary year. "

Friday, 15 July 2016

#brexit - what are the #negotiating positions the UK can take? @LSEpoliticsblog


Preamable 

Read this 1st bit to get into some of the mindset of a professional commercial negotiator.  Then use that understanding to consider how the various parties might approach the Brexit negotiations.

Negotiations are governed by which person has the power in the commercial relationship.

To understand where the power lies careful thinking is usually wise before negotiations start.  

Which "red lines" can't your negotiating team cross?  At what point do you walk away from negotiations (for real as opposed to a piece of negotiating theatre).   How do you signal these positions to the other side so as to allow negotiation towards but not beyond them? How far are you able to bluff on what your red lines are?  But take care on bluffing. Remember once a bluff is called you're future negotiating position is stuffed if you actually have to continue to negotiate.  

Often who has the power in a negotiation can be indicated by analysis about who is under time pressure to do the deal.  Or an assessment of who can really walk away from the deal.  Or the market reality about how unique the sellers product is.

So if you're a supplier of something that is wanted or fairly rare or only available for a short time or in demand - and you have a pushy buyer wanting special rates/terms then .....

... you might be able to decide you won't do business with the buyer if they insist on special discounts.  After all you have lots of other willing customers.  If you give one a discount then if your other customers find out they will want a discount as well and your profit rate may go down (Ceteris paribus);

 ... basically as a seller in this kind of position you can trump the buyer's "give me a discount" pitch with "Non".  

Given this fairly brief intro to some of the dynamics in commercial negotiations ....



what are the brexit negotiating positions UK can take?



Option 1 - enact article 50 then negotiate on the terms of the UK leaving the EU - from a UK Brexit perspective this has a certain attraction in terms of getting on with it and trying to calm the financial markets. Although its equally possible that as facts from negotiations emerge the financial markets might get spooked.  

The major problem with this approach is that under Article 50 the EU negotiators can just spin the negotiations out to 2 years at which point the UK is chucked out.  

So basically the EU has the ability to time out the negotiations. They have almost all the power once Article 50 is enacted.  Which of course is one of the reasons why the initial EU response to Brexit was along the lines of "OK  - fair enough - democracy has spoken - but we won't negotiate till you enact clause 50".  

Once the 2 year Article 50 clock is clicking the UK won't have a position of power to negotiate from.  The only way round that problem is to agree with the EU to turn the clock off.  The argument for a clock off agreement might be along the lines of "It has taken us over 40 years to put the various trading & commerce arrangements in place.  Time limiting how long it takes to unpick or change these is unrealistic".

My guess would be that the EU negotiators won't turn the 2 year clock off - because it gives them such a powerful negotiating position.



Option 2  - don't enact Article 50 until the EU agree to specific fundamental undertakings about the UK Brexit.  To which the EU (given its current position) would probably say "get lost". 

So one UK response to such a "Nein"  might be as follows ...

"We are still EU members and £ contributors. Till you agree to some fundamental undertakings before we enact Article 50 we'll use the full weight of our membership and legal and veto rights to make EU management very, very, very difficult.".  

Of course this is a fairly nuclear approach and relations would sink to an all time low.  But in such a situation the EU is hampered from getting on with its business till it it can get rid of the UK. And the "lets leave the EU" factions in other countries might feed off this disruption to try to get an in/out referendum in their country.

With this option the major problem is that it largely destroys the working relationships. And of course a lot of care would have to be taken over how legally binding the pre-negotiation undertakings were.  

But some may argue that the relationships are going south fast already.  And of course this option does go some way to making the negotiating power positions between the EU and the UK more even.



Option 3 - enact or don't Article 50 - Such an approach might work if the UK's aim is to exit the EU trading arrangements and create/use other trade deals with the rest of the world. Indeed there are already some arguments emerging in the media along these lines ...

"Why would we want to stay with a stagnant low growth market only representing part of Europe?  Lets create trade deals with India and China and the USA and Pacific nations and Africa - those are the markets where growth is good"

For Brexit supporters this option also has the greatest chance of delivering on their rhetoric on "Taking back Control" and on initiating the EU citizen border controls they want.

But you'll notice that some EU members are already claiming that the UK can't legally negotiate with other parties before it enacts Article 50 to exit the EU.  

Although this argument seems open to challenge given that the rest of the EU members have already "informally" met together to discuss Brexit.  (I think they used the "informally" sleight of hand to get round the technicality of them holding discussions without the UK).  



So these are the three main negotiating options I can think of if "Brexit means Brexit" in the words of our new PM.  

The Brexit negotiations are set to be a fascinating insight into political and trade negotiations.

And doubtless they'll be several books, dissertations and doctoral studies on them over the next couple of years.









Wednesday, 13 July 2016

2min 25 sec clip - #Cameron's Lament

A short musical fantasy developing a motif as sung by David Cameron as he entered no.10 Downing Street on 11 July 2016. Written and recorded hastily between midnight and 2am on 12 July 2016.

Monday, 2 May 2016

#brexit or #ues2eu ? - "We believe in our own democracy. They see #Europe as the symbol of a liberal democracy"

Image from wikipedia
This posts title is a quote from @BBCRadio4 's "The Reunion" programme on the Maastricht Treaty

In that programme Sue MacGregor is joined Lord Lamont  a former chancellor, Ken Clarke who replaced him, the Government Whip responsible for Europe, David Davies, and Conservative backbencher Sir Bill Cash, a prominent Euro-rebel, as well as John Major's Private Secretary for Foreign Affairs and later the Official Historian on Britain's Relationship with Europe, Sir Stephen Wall.

At the 39:24 time mark in the programme David Davies says the following on the reasons why the UK is different from many of the other countries in the EU.....

"
- the Germans and Italians came into the original Iron & Steel community from a dictatorship,

- the Spainards came in from Franco,

- the Portuguese came in from Katana,

- the Greeks came in from the Colonels,

- Eastern Europe came in from under the jackboot of Soviet domination,

- We came in after 150 years of liberal democracy that worked quite well.

So our attitude to Europe is not the same as theirs.  

We believe in our own democracy.

They see Europe as the symbol of a liberal democracy.

Its a very different viewpoint."

Sunday, 24 April 2016

Journalism & the #Brexit debate #Polis2016 - the focus on the economy, the fact free ghetto of social media, the UK media's power - and why weren't 16 years olds allowed to vote?

Last Thursday I attended the #Polis2016 conference at LSE, London, UK.   I've already done two earlier posts on parts of the conference:

- one on Jon Snow's opening address - at which he gave some priceless advice (given the venue) "if you want to be a journalist don't do a journalism degree"

- and another on a conference session about Reporting Refugees  - from which I was reminded that "Good #storytelling isn't limited to simplified representations of reality"


Another great scribes on 'Reporting Refugees' from





This post is about some of the ideas that came out from the session on the UK referendum on Yes or No to EU membership

X


1) Its the economy stupid - part of the panel discussion  was on how the main thrust of the In campaign has focused on the economy and the bad effects on it if the UK exits the EU. At the same time it was mentioned that the Out campaign had been forced to battle on this economic ground as the "self governance" argument is seen as having little traction with voters.

One of the journalists from abroad on the panel commented on how much of UK political debate seemed to focus on economic matters.  Others on the panel pointed out the effect the economic arguments had in helping the Stay campaign in the Scottish referendum - and indeed in the Conservatives gaining sole power at the last general election.  

A final thread of this part of the discussion was on the stories that hadn't been reported:

- the UK's impact on the EU (e.g. on competition policy/free trade);
- the role of the EU in helping to maintain peace in Europe;
- how the EU institutions actually work (because its a hard story to make interesting?).

This part of the debate led me to make a mental note ...





2) Fact checking and the echo chamber of social media - One of the panel described "the Facebook echo chamber where people hear views they agree with echoed back to them"

This theme of confirmation bias came up in this and at least one other of the conference sessions.


panel on reporting on said social media can be a "fact free ghetto" where people only hear what they want


What I didn't hear pointed out is how the algorithms used in social media magnify this confirmation bias. For more on this see this post on facebook ... the takeaway from which is - social media amplifies confirmation bias because its algorithms are designed to present you with content you'll be interested in based on what you - and your friends - have already viewed, shared or liked.

This confirmation bias even seems remarkably robust against facts

. runs fact checking project but judgement already being clouded by emotion, & often incorrect stats



3) The power of the UK media in framing debates - in comments about the Scottish referendum some on the panel said it showed how the power of mainstream media in the UK is weakening (but maybe this was also the anti-Westminster bubble effect in Scotland?)

However the French and German journalists on the panel both commented on how much more powerful than their press the UK press was in setting the agenda for debate. (An example given was how the European press perspective on the deal Cameron got was that he did very well. Yet most of the UK press promoted a "he didn't do well" storyline).

There was also a debate on the uniqueness of the BBC in the UK media landscape - the equivalent of which doesn't exist in many other European countries. The role of the BBC in occupying an unbiased position of presenting "on the one hand and on the other arguments" was seen to be fairly unique. But it also has some downsides ...

tells conf. BBC et al efforts 2b very fair sometimes make it hard for journos to dismiss some claims as wrong

And I heard one complaint (from the audience maybe) about "Those idiots on the Today programme setting the agenda"


4) Why didn't Cameron lower the voting age to 16 for the referendum? Was an interesting question asked but not answered. Particularly as there would be a higher likelihood of young people voting to stay in the EU - and not forgetting the effect such a move had in energising the debate in the Scottish referendum.

A side point made was that when 16 year olds are given the vote then schools can help educate them on how to vote (so what you do in a polling booth or with a postal vote) and help them actually register to vote. This is help not available to 18 year olds (or older) in their 1st voting opportunity. And maybe it is one of the factors that influence why so many younger voters don't vote - embarrassment about not knowing how to.