license

Creative Commons License
Where the stuff on this blog is something i created it is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License so there are no requirements to attribute - but if you want to mention me as the source that would be nice :¬)
Showing posts with label lecture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lecture. Show all posts

Wednesday, 21 February 2018

Why #socialmedia demands a revolution in #mission - a lecture sponsored by @youthscape and @stmellitus

This Monday I attended the 1st ever annual youthwork lecture sponsored by @Youthscape and @stmellitus .  It was held at  St. Mellitus College in Collingham Road, London SW5.  With a #SMCYS hashtag for tweets on the event its Eventbrite information was titled "The Stories In Which We Find Ourselves: Why social media demands a revolution in mission".


Free audio form the event is here.  The event was specifically aimed at those working with young people.  But the issues it raised on social media obviously have a wider application to all social media users the church engages with. The picture below is a mega summary of the points I took away. What follows after that is my take on the event in more detail - along with some of the slides shown and commentary provided by the speakers.  




As it happens the event coincided with some other events on similar topics this week:

- Monday's seminar in Oxford entitled Theological Futures: Digital and Ecological  - discussing issues like 'What is the nature of the “hope” that will be required for human beings to navigate the challenges posed to us by the contemporary ecological crisis? '

- Tuesday's #liedentity conference run by the Diocese of Gloucester with @BishGloucester- which addressed the growing issue of negative body image and the resulting mental and physical health difficulties especially for young people.

- Today's announcement that MPs on the Commons Science and Technology Committee are to investigate the impact of social media and screens on youth. "We want to determine the scale of the issues - separating out the understandable concerns from the hard evidence, and to identify what practical measures people are already taking to boost the benefits and blunt the potential harms. "



A BIT MORE DETAIL

Doors opened 6pm, nibbles and drinks were available and the event started at 6.30pm and finished 8.30pm.  



Introduction

After a brief series of plugs for St. Mellitus courses and some Youthscape research coming out next Monday St. Mellitus' Alice Smith @youthworkmum - their youth work tutor - 

introduced the event and its format. There were three parts to the lecture - a short overview of social media platforms, a longer reflection on the philosophical/theological issues surrounding social media, a third section on thoughts as to what this all meant for youth workers and a Q&A at the end. 




An overview of young people's use of social media


@lahnapottle - a specialist on 16-19 year olds from Youthscape - led this first session.  Lahna gave a quick overview of Snapchat, Instagram, Twitter, You Tube, WhatsApp, Facebook and music.ly .  Common features across many of these platforms were various filters for editing pictures to allow the "perfect" selfie to be posted. 

- Some like Snapchat and Instagram only kept pictures shared for a limited time before they were deleted and gone for ever, (although as I recall other apps/phones can capture smartphone screen images - so the auto-delete functionality doesn't guarantee pictures won't be stored elsewhere and shared later).  

- Snapchat's Streaks feature keeps track of the number of consecutive days of messaging between friends - so people refer to a "200 day streak" - and some young people use this measure to quantify how serious their friendships are.

- Youtube's autoplay feature starts up the next clip when the current one has finished.  So people can easily spend a lot of time on youtube watching clips served up to them by the sites' algorithms.  90% of 13-17yr olds use YouTube and the site has created a number of new stars.  Younger people watch more youtube than cable or TV.

- A current top 10 app for 11-13 year olds is Musical.ly on which you can film a lip sync video to share within the app.  The app has created a number of musical.ly lip synching stars.

- Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat users were 3-4 times more likely to come across cyber-bullying, (compared with twitter and you-tube users)

- Facebook and Instagram were the worst in terms of their impact on well-being and mental health.

Lahna had limited time to cover a vast subject.  So by necessity there must have been much she'd have liked to say but didn't have time for.  From my perspective I guess I'd add the following three points to her overview of social media apps ...

1) social media platforms are not neutral.  Of course they market themselves as a neutral platform that individuals can use to interact with others and express themselves.  But they are also businesses which promise advertisers, (and those seeking to influence elections), highly targetable options to get their message to the right people.  All of this functionality uses the data we reveal via our online interactions and which we often don't knowingly give specific and explicit permission to be used.  (Thus the well known social media quote - "If the product is free you are the product").

2) social media apps amplify our own unconscious bias.  They use algorithms to work out what we like and view and then serve up more of the same to us.  So they magnify our unconscious bias to follow and listen to those with views and tastes similar to our own.

3) the larger social media companies behave just like monopoly suppliers.  Their owners promote themselves as innovators and entrepreneurs facilitating a better and more informed world.  But as they become big capitalist businesses they tend to behave like a monopoly - creating expensive barriers to entry to markets and/or buying out any competitors before they become a threat.  So for example  - Facebook bought Instagram for $1 billion in 2012 and acquired WhatsApp in 2014 for $19 billion.



How can philosophy and theology help in understanding social media


Dr John McDade, ( former Principal of Heythrop College, University of London ), then talked through some of the philosophical and theological issues around social media. 

In doing so he shared various quotes from other thinkers on some of the deeper issues around understanding ourselves and our self image.  I've arranged some of John's insights around some themes that I discerned when reviewing his slides and points.  ( I make this point as John didn't explicitly have "headings" to sections of his lecture).


The modern world and Christianity

Towards the beginning of his lecture John made a comment something like "people don't want to feel about themselves the way they think Christianity will make them feel".  He also showed the quote below to make the point that the current pope - unlike the previous two - isn't fighting with modernity. 



Later on in the lecture one of his slides had the following quote "God is missing and is not missed" - and after that the slide made this point -  "Many people now live in a de-sacralised world in which God is not mentioned, but in which digital versions of reality are increasingly pervasive.  Are these related?"  

What I took from these points was that christians need to recognise that the world has changed and it won't be changing back to some fondly remembered arrangement in which traditional approaches to mission worked.  So if we want to engage with the world - mission - we need to change how we do that.


Humans - wonderfully made but imperfect

On one slide John wrote "The worship of false gods in which we invest our intention is only to be expected".  On another slide, (below), he reflected on humans' imperfections.


On the theme of idols his slides had several quotes ...

- "Recognising idols for what they are does not break their enchantment" WH Auden

- "A society whose members are helpless need idols" Erich Fromm

- "Man differs from the other animals in his greater aptitude for imitation" Aristotle

John summarised some of this on a slide which said that - for Girard - imitation is closely linked to desire, desire is linked to need (neglect), need drives us toward idols and unreality.

Believe in your Selfie - What I took from these points is that although made in the image of God humans are pre-disposed to replace God with idols - which they then try to imitate to feel needed. Social media is just the latest tool that allows us to replace God with idols. 


The impact of digital culture on the sense of self and the sense of God



Using a combination of slides and commentary John described how as a child he had played cowboys and Indians - and in that make believe world he had "killed" hundreds of Indians.  He pondered whether virtual/digital reality might infantilise us with its elements of play-acting (masquerade).  Pre social media this "playing" was evident in how pop-stars, (think Madonna or Bowie), reinvented themselves several times.  The arrival of social media created a way for more people to re-invent themselves in an imagined second self.

John quoted Pascal (1623-62) and his insights on :

- our dissatisfaction with our lives "we are not satisfied with the life we have in ourselves and our own being.  We want to lead an imaginary life in the eyes of others and so to make an impression"

- how imagination allows us to escape that dissatisfaction - "imagination is the dominant faculty in people, master of error and falsehood, all the more deceptive for not being invariably so"

He also quoted D Bromwich on the physical self, second self theme - "It is not enough for us to be real to ourselves within ourselves.  We want to be completely special, yet we want to be completely normal."

Briefly John also looked at the use of avatars in digital games and realities - how quickly people identified with their avatar and how some people thought that together - the physical and the digital  - "we make one complete person".


He also relayed a story from 2007 of a married couple who - separately - using false names in an online chat room   thought they had found their soulmate who they could pour their heart out to.

Sonia 27 ("Sweetie" in the chatroom) - "I was suddenly in love.  It was amazing, we seemed to be stuck in the same kind of miserable marriages"

So they arranged a physical date with each other - only to discover that the other person was in fact their current partner.  In 2007 they were getting divorced and accusing each other of being unfaithful.

Adnan 32 ("Prince of Joy" in the chatroom) - "I still find it hard to believe that Sweetie, who wrote such wonderful things, is actually the same women I married who has not said a nice word to me for years"

All of these observations led to some questions


and some observations ....


also ...

- what we attend to is what we worship,

- how do we help people develop a truthful sense of self?


And now for some theology

Across a number of slides John summarised James A Smith's "Desiring the kingdom; Worship, Worldview and cultural formation" and his four features of our nature ....

1. Humans are intentional creatures whose way of 'intending' [directing their focus and purpose] is LOVE or DESIRE.

2. This love (often unconscious and non-cognitive) is always aimed at some particular version of the good life.  (We aim always to flourish even though we make bad choices).

3. There are always sets of habits and dispositions that prime us to be oriented, and to act, in certain ways.  (What your body does your soul registers).

4. Affective, bodily means, such as bodily practices, routines and rituals, grab hold of the heart through the imagination and form the person.  (We always shape or condition ourselves: and the way we do this folds back on the way we are).  You are never without your conditioner!  We create a culture that express our nature, and in turn that nature comes back and re-models us.


So as John sees it - 

- Smith offers a perspective on the formation of identity that shifts the focus away from an issue of 'knowledge' (what I believe at the level of ideas) to one of 'affect' or 'affection' (what or whom do I love?)

- Generally religious people place too much emphasis on what people believe conceptually. 'Hope' is a more interesting opening on the human heart.

- What do the rituals of your body tell you to be?

- The task for humans is how to find our way to non-idolatrous worship.

- "These days, most people do not name as 'gods' the gods they worship" (N. Lash, Holiness, Speech and Silence 38).

- Love requires practice, and practices confirm and express love.  Smith thinks of two kinds of practices or habits



In more on thin practices John set out that ,,,

- Thin practices might have unintended consequences such as their effect on the way we think and feel.  We can be shaped by trivial matters.

- No practice is neutral - there is always some goal (human flourishing in some fashion) and there is always some effect.

- Is dependence on digital reality a 'thin' habit?  Or ....


On more detail on Thick habits John set out that ...

- Smith analyses and evaluates a range of activities as 'liturgies', 'rituals of worship'

- Liturgies are 'ritual practices that function as pedagogies of ultimate desire (87)
(Note: ped . a .go . gy  - n. 1) the art or profession of teaching, 2) preparatory training or instruction)

- There can be 'secular' activities that are in fact 'rituals of worship'



Thoughts as to what this all means for youth workers


In the final session @martinsaunders shared some thoughts on practical ideas from the various points and observation in the lecture.  He had four points:


Young people need space to find the real them ... without the filters that social media apps provide.  A chance to look at their "1st attempt selfie".  Of course for youth workers this equally challenges them to ask whether they have found the real me.

Teenagers find adventure and purpose in online communities ... and we need to help them accept the adventure of a radical Christian life.

The non-stop digital life is exhausting ... provide refuge experiences of meditation, fasting and silence to allow people to unhook and reflect.

The world of young people has changed ... we need to understand those changes to gain an insight into how young people experience life.


Related links
- a recent study on teens and social media




Saturday, 30 May 2015

the importance of #character

The Road to CharacterI listened to this RSA lunchtime lecture this last Thursday - David Brooks was the speaker on the subject of a book he has just written.

What follows is a mega summary of the lecture...    

.... and then a bit more detail created from some the ideas that particularly struck me.  

At the foot of this post are links to some other posts you may find useful.

Mega Summary



 link to this tweet
. "We focus much more on how to build a good career rather than a good character"

to build character you need to:

1) be self aware of your good and bad points;

2) let that awareness and your experience of life (including love & suffering) affect the humility and empathy and generosity with which you treat others;

3) focus not on your value but on your service to others



and in a bit more detail ...



David Brooks started off by talking about incandescent people  - like the Dali Lama  - and their inner glow.  In looking at such people he had started to think about how he could achieve that inner glow himself.

He then went on to describe 2 differing focus people seem to have in their lives


1) some seem to focus on their CV virtues - that is things they are good at, that are helpful for getting a good job and successful career

2) others seem to focus on their Eulogy virtues - the things that people will say about them at their funeral




He described these different approaches as "Adam 1" and "Adam 2" (taken from The Lonely Man of Faith by Rabbi Joseph B Soloveitchik) 


Adam 1 - the CV virtues - so an economic focus typified by words like logic, practice & produce & perfect, calculating, shrewd, work focused, conquer, venture, win

Adam 2 - Eulogy virtues - so typified by words like humility, love, doing good, vocation, selflessness, generosity and self sacrifice



David suggested that our culture is out of balance with a focus on Adam 1.

So we are taught to brand ourselves, to have a good career, to focus on our self interest, to broadcast ourselves via social media.  Children are told to love themselves, that they are wonderful inside - to be "true to yourself"





Indeed using Google Ngrams he said that we can see that the use of "economic" Adam 1 type words is increasing ...
whilst the use of "moral" Adam 2 type words is decreasing ...

He also mentioned a survey which asked College students which they would choose - a life of fame or a life of sex.  Most picked fame


'80% of young people think they are really important' Hence increased desire for fame


David then went on to describe how he had looked at various people to see how to develop a moral life and the activities that would help - bravery, gratitude, kindness, humility


so he talked about Eisenhower ....




and how a childhood experience taught Eisenhower about acknowledging the anger he had inside - "the key confrontation is against yourself" - so he could manage his anger and so lead others

then David talked about Samuel Johnson - with his OCD tendancies



and pointed out that such confrontation of our inner flaws increases our empathy for others


David next talked about Francis Perkins and her commitment to work safety that arose from seeing a fire in a factory where people threw themselves out of upper storey windows and so fell to their death - to escape the intense heat.  He thought that Francis embraced a call within her - a vocation - what life was demanding of her


and the final example David gave was George Elliot  - and how love humbles, how it ploughs open hard ground, how it de-centres us from from ourselves 



We then turned to a Q&A - various quotes from the Q&A session are below



Dissatisfaction with neuroscience revolution brought to 'character'


David mentioned a reading list of 14 books he gives his students - this maybe close

"do you want to have a little impact over a large no. of people or do you want to have a larger impact over a few people? "



"but social media does encourage shallow short interactions rather than deeper longer ones"


"the message is the person - think of how Pope Francis is"


"Volunteering for worthy causes doesn't necessarily build character - that is confusing the external with the internal"




other posts on RSA, TED, other lectures, conferences, others blog posts
11 headlines on why we use facebook & social media - summarised out of a very rich buffer post by Courtney Seiteron  
18 top tips and thoughts about using #social media to enable #community source = an article by  Anatoliy Gruzd PhD & Caroline Haythornthwaite PhD 

2014
Data Protection & Privacy - 8 issues from an International Conference
escape your social horizon limit & understand more - source = a blog post summarising the work of  Jeffrey A. Smith, Miller McPherson & Lynn Smith-Lovin
social media & death - 10 things you may not have thought about - #DORS conference

2013
the development of the U2 spyplane - source = CIA historians Gregory Pedlow & Donald Welzenbach
considering culture and business process improvement  - source = an article by Schmiedel, Theresa, vom Brocke, Jan, & Recker 
ideas that may help you attract older volunteers - source = a paper by Brayley, Nadine, Obst, Patricia L., White, Katherine M., Lewis, Ioni M.,Warburton, Jeni, & Spencer, Nancy
physical factors which help people get better quicker - source = a paper by Salonen, Heidi & Morawska, Lidia 
a new approach to school and education - by Geetha Narayanan 
guiding principles on designing construction kits - by Mitchel Resnick & Brian Silverman
signs of overparenting - source = an article by Locke, Judith, Campbell, Marilyn A., & Kavanagh, David J
making ideas happen - source = a 99U conference

2012
how to spot a liar - by pamela myer 
measuring happiness - source = talk by jim clifton, jim harter, ben leedle